Friday, June 22, 2012

Damage

I hate hit points.  I've gotten to the point that when I play dnd it's hard for me to not to think of all the characters like gummy bears.  No blood, no internal organ, or anything like that.  Just a pool of matter that can be carved away one hit at a time until the character is finally dead and gone.

I've seen games that have really realistic damage systems, but the problem is that a lot of those systems are very slow or require a lot of complex math.  First off: math is a part of gaming, but at this point most systems have pretty basic equations.  I think a thresh hold system that uses simple math is doable.  Will it be the most realistic system ever?  No, but what I want is something that's believably realistic and smooth running.  I'd take perfectly realistic and smooth running, but I don't think that's on the table right now.

So, what have I got?

Well, Dead Lands had a thresh hold system that I liked, but I'm not just using it.  There's was based on size and unless you had a merit or flaw that changed your size category everyone took damage equally.  I still think that Con should factor in, but when I look at the D20 system, I think: Yes, a dragon w/a 30 con should be better off than a human w/ a 30 con.  So, I think size and armor will both play a role in this.
Essentially I want the formula to follow: size+con+armor+feats/perks+misc modifiers=threshold.

So, if a medium creature were size 1, then a human w/ a con of two would be a threshold of 3.  That means that every three points of damage is a wound level.  I'm planning on having 5 wound levels: Flesh, light, moderate, severe, and maimed.  Every three points will be a level of damage.
So, 1-3:Flesh, 4-6 light, etc.
Heroes will suffer pain penalty's, blood loss, and shock (subdual damage) based on the wound level they take.

I don't want to use the same math for everything, but I have some basic ideas.  Some friends of mine came up with a blood system for a game they called: Lords of War.  In it an average person had 30 points of blood.  Some how, this number has stuck with me as the norm.  So, If I want an average guy to have 30 blood points.  However, I don't want the progression to be too steep.  What I'm thinking is 15+(Con+size+perks+misc)X5.  So an average person would again have 1 size and 2 con making them a 30.

Shock I haven't quite worked out yet.  Too little and the heroe's go out like a light.  Too much and it becomes a non-factor.  Right now, I'm thinking 15+ConX5 for that.

Armor, for my current line of thinking I've been having the "AC" bonus of armor in DnD just be a thresh hold bonus instead.  So, a guy w/ a con of 2 would be Size:1+Con:2+armor:8=11.  It'll be hard to do any more than a flesh wound using the current damage system for DnD.  I'm going to be tinkering with that.  Don't get me wrong:  Armor should protect you, but I don't want a hero to be invulnerable either.

Essentially I'm looking at the wounds working like this:
Flesh: little to no bleeding, some shock, some pain
Light: bleeding, shock, pain
Moderate: more bleeding, more shock,  more pain
Severe: Even More bleeding, more shock, lots of pain.
Maimed: Extreme bleeding, shock, and pain.  Also the limb will be rendered useless and if it's a head or torso hit, the hero may die (More on this later).

The amount of shock, pain, and bleeding will be determined by the type of weapon, but I haven't worked that out yet, either.

Essentially, when a hero takes a hit.  Damage will be rolled and applied against his thresh hold.  Depending on the wound level he will take shock damage (which could knock him out on the spot), pain modifiers will be applied to any future rolls the hero makes and bleeding will be noted.  The hero does not take any blood damage until his initiative though.  On the hero's initiative is when he bleeds.  A character will bleed from every wound they have, but only take pain from the highest level wound.  Also, a hit location roll should be used on each hit to determine where the wound is located.  I use a simple D10, but a lot of games have their own. 

I'm looking for a system that is dramatic and has a built in sense of urgency, but is also quick enough that it doesn't bog game play down.  I've even decided that when I run it, I'm going to give the players their blood points and they're going to have to give them back to me when they bleed.  Imagine sitting at the table w/ 30 red poker chips or red magic counterstones in front of you.  Your hero takes a light wound and on your next turn you have to give me one leaving you w/ 29.  Then your hero takes a severe wound.  So, on your next initiative you bleed from both wounds: you have to give up 4 tokens.  Now, you have 25 left.  Your hero takes a moderate wound and that's two more tokens each round, so next time you give up 6.  Your hero is bleeding to death and without some kind of healing, he will keel over in the middle of battle.

I'll have to go into more detail on this when I talk about my thoughts for armor and weapons.  That's down the road a ways for me.  But, I hope this gives you something to chew on.

Thursday, June 21, 2012

stats

Stats.

I don't know where to begin. I tend to be hateful of them because this is where the power gaming begins for most players. We use these numbers to define our characters and it wasn't long before some gamer somewhere started figuring out which combinations of numbers would best serve their characters. I hate the idea of the throw away stat, but it's a term I've used before.

I'm especially critical of mental and social stats. I've seen too many characters with 6 chr, who try to speak as eloquently as possible. Guys with college educations who make fighters with 7 int. I've seen the opposite as well. I've seen idiots with 18 int wizards and the like.

So, what is the purpose of stats?
Stats should inform us of who the character, but they should not dominate. That's the trick of it and one that I have not yet figured out.

The first thing to do is to make the stats more equal. Strength and Dexterity are the worst of all the offenders. In D20 Strength is both to hit for melee combat and damage bonus. Dexterity is even worse. It covers AC, ranged combat, the reflext save, and initiative. With the right feats it will even control melee to hit. To me, that makes it too powerful.

What I've developed is a system where each stat covers as few bases as possible. That makes them more balanced.
In my game:
Str will determine lifting/carrying ability and melee damage.
Dex will determine defense and reflex saves
Con will determine the amount of damage that can be taken and fortitude saves.

I've gotten rid of the tradition mental and social stats and introduced 3 new ones.
Grit. This is a measure of mental endurance and ability to do harm. I subscribe to the philosophy that not everyone is capable of bringing violence on those around them and that ability is measured by grit. Grit determines melee to hit and will saves.
Perception. This measures sensory ability and accuity so it tracks spot, listen, search, it also will determine ranged attack.
Power: This is just a stat used to determine how powerful a character's magic can be.

I dream of a game where instead of numbers stats and characters are described with adjectives. Instead of having a strength of one, a hero's strength might be 'average' or 'strong'. However, since quantitative and qualitative data are linked, it's hard to get away from assigning hard values to those adjectives.

Also: Like most games I'm moving away from having a number that gives a modifier the way that DnD does. If an 18 give you +4 then your stat is essentially a 4.

I'm also a big fan of the idea that stats should be paid for separately in point based character creation, or that at the minimum: limits should be set on how high stats can be and how many high stats a character can have. Especially in systems where flaws can be taken to gain extra points that can be spent on stats.

Monday, June 18, 2012

Intro

I've been gaming, that is: playing pen and paper role playing games, for around 16 years.  I sat down to play my first session of Robotech in Lacey Washington in the 8th grade.  I was 13, but it was only a few months before I turned 14. 

More than the killing monsters or amassing treasure, I love the telling the story.  That's what's great about rpgs.  We get to come together and tell a story that could potentially be better than any movie, tv show, book, or anything else.

I've played a lot of games over the years and I've seen a lot of good ideas and, unfortunately, a lot of bad ideas.  I'm pickiest about fantasy games.  Fantasy games, like dnd, are the most rules and logistic intensive, but they're also the ones that have the fewest innovations.  I like the fantasy genre, but I haven't been totally happy in a classic fantasy campaign in a LONG time.

Like most gamers I've played around with house rules, but they're not enough for me.  For me to get the fantasy game I want, I've decided that the answer is to start at the ground and work my way up:
 Rules
World
Campaign

I'm using the D20 system as a template, but I'm changing a ton and including a lot of good ideas from other systems as well.  I want rules that work with the narrative and help promote story telling.  Plus I'll be looking for other ways to enrich my game.